Short Sales and Foreclosures in 2014

/

The Law After the Expiration of the Mortgage Debt Relief Act

Before you consider a short sale or foreclosure in 2014, here is the law you should know.

First, there are two types of debts. They are unsecured and secured. Unsecured debt is the bare promise to pay. The most common form is credit card debt. Secured debt, on the other hand, has two parts. The first part is the bare promise to pay which on a car loan or real estate loan is the Promissory Note. What makes secured debt different than unsecured debt is the security given by the borrower to ensure the promise is kept. This security on real property is called a Deed of Trust.

Second, on real estate loans, there are two different types of promises to pay. Non-Recourse or Recourse. A Non-recourse loans is (1) the loan or loans obtained to purchase a 1-4 unit property in which the borrower occupies at least one unit  (2) seller carry back or (3) a refinance after 1/1/13 with no cash out. Everything else is recourse debt i.e. the refinance of the real property with cash out, lines of credit, the loan or loans used to purchase a rental property.

Third, personal liability depends on whether you do a short sale or foreclosure. If you do a short sale, California Code of Civil Procedure (“CCP”) 580e provides that there can be no deficiency owed, collected, requested or rendered for any lender approved short sale of a one to four unit dwelling.  What this means is that a property owner cannot be held personally liable if the lender has agreed to the short sale. 

If a property is foreclosed in a non-judicial sale, you will not have any personal liability as to the loan that is foreclosed on because California is an anti-deficiency state i.e. the lender waives its right to come after you on the loan that they foreclosed on.  However, if there are junior liens to the foreclosing lien, they will have the right to sue you after the foreclose. They are called “sold out” junior i.e. they lost their lien, but they still have the promise to pay and thus have the right to sue you on the promissory note.

Fourth, in every short sale or foreclosure, there are potential tax implications. The IRS/Franchise Tax Board (“FTB”) wants to know two things. (1) Did you make any money on the deal and (2) Did you borrow any money which was not repaid.  If you made money on the deal including taking out cash to buy another house, buy another car, pay off credit card, you may have gain. If you borrowed money which is not repaid either through a foreclosure, you may Cancellation of Debt Income (“CODI”).   The great news on the short sales in 2014  is that both the FTB and the IRS have agreed that there is no CODI on short sales pursuant to CCP 580e.  However, these rulings do not apply to foreclosures.  There are exceptions to the CODI which will apply on foreclosures, but they are limited.

In conclusion, a short sale or foreclosure without legal advice is like jumping into the middle of the ocean with no life vest. Don’t do it.   Do not take on liability which could have been eliminated or reduced with first obtaining legal advice.  I see people every day for a free consultation on short sales and foreclosures in Walnut Creek and Brentwood.

WE ARE A DEBT RELIEF AGENCY. WE HELP PEOPLE FILE BANKRUPTCY RELIEF UNDER THE BANKRUPTCY CODE. THIS INFORMATION IS NOT PROVIDED AS LEGAL ADVICE AND SHOULD NOT BE RELIED UPON IN MAKING ANY DECISION REGARDING A  SHORT SALE OR FORECLOSURE. THIS INFORMATION IS NOT A SUBSTITUTE FOR OBTAINING TAX & LEGAL ADVICE REGARDING AN INDIVIDUAL SITUATION.

© 2014 Joan Grimes

Debt Settlement vs. Bankruptcy

/

Clients come into my office every week saying that they are in a debt settlement plan, BUT are now being sued by a creditor or they have received a 1099c income statement from a creditor that was included in the debt settlement plan.  How can this be?

First, just because you are in a debt settlement plan, it does not mean that a creditor cannot sue you on account.  It happens every day.  In some cases, the lawsuit is because a debt could not be included in the settlement because a creditor would not agree.  In other cases, the reason for the lawsuit was that the creditor was not receiving payments from the debt settlement plan in an amount that would satisfy the creditor.   

Second, just because you are in a debt settlement plan, it does not mean that the creditor will not issue you a 1099c for that portion of the debt which is forgiven.  In fact,  the IRS REQUIRES creditors to issue a 1099c to individuals where more than $600 in debt is forgiven.  Therefore, if you settle with a VISA for $5,000 on a $50,000 bill, you will receive a $45,000 1099c which will be considered income to you and will be taxed at your current tax rate.

Third, just because you are in a debt settlement/consolidation plan, it does not mean that your credit will not affected or that creditors will stop calling you.  Creditors can still contact you for the collection of debts they are owed unless or until you file bankruptcy. Also, a debt settlement program will impact your credit in the future and have long-term side effects because you will have late payments and even when you settle, your credit report will not show that the account was paid in full.

Debt settlement plans are alternatives to bankruptcy.  If you do not qualify for bankruptcy, then you will have no choice but to proceed with the settlement or consolidation plan. However, most people DO qualify for bankruptcy and in fact, most qualify for a Chapter 7 which requires NO payments back to creditors.  Even, if you do not qualify for a Chapter 7, the payments in Chapter 13 will in almost every instance be significantly lower than what you are paying to the debt settlement or consolidation company.  Better yet, there will be no 1099c received after the bankruptcy because Bankruptcy is one of the exceptions to the debt forgiveness rule.

In conclusion, these are very tough times.  You are not alone.  If you are having trouble paying your bills as they come due, I recommend you seek legal counsel before you enter into a debt settlement or consolidation plan.  Know all of your options and then you will be able to make the best decision for you and your family.  I see people for a FREE 30 minute consultation at my offices locate in Walnut Creek, Antioch and Brentwood.

THIS INFORMATION IS NOT PROVIDED AS LEGAL ADVICE AND SHOULD NOT BE RELIED UPON IN                        MAKING ANY DECISION REGARDING A VOLUNTARY DEFAULT, SHORT SALE, FORECLOSURE OR BANKRUPTCY.  THIS INFORMATION IS NOT A SUBSTITUTE FOR OBTAINING TAX & LEGAL ADVICE REGARDING AN INDIVIDUAL SITUATION.   GRIMESBKLAW.COM  (925) 323-7772     © 2011 Joan Grimes