1099-C Cancellation of Debt

There is a common belief that a 1099-C means that the debt in question has been cancelled and that no further collection may be made by the creditor.  However, this is not the law.  A 1099-C filed by a creditor with the IRS, standing alone, does not mean that the debt has been cancelled.

Pursuant to the Internal Revenue Code, creditors are required to file 1099-C even though an actual discharge of indebtedness has not yet occurred or is even contemplated.  Rather, there may be an event “deemed” to constitute a discharge of the debt solely for purposes of determining the reporting requirement to the IRS.  The courts have held that a “Form 1099-C” is not an admission by the creditor that it has discharged the debt or can no longer pursue collection.

Pursuant the IRS regulations, there are 8 identifiable events which require the creditor to file a 1099-C: (1) a discharge of indebtedness in bankruptcy (2) a cancellation or extinguishment of an indebtedness in a receivership, foreclosure or similar proceeding (3) a cancellation or extinguishment of debt upon the expiration of the statute of limitation (4) a cancellation or extinguishment pursuant to an election of remedies (5) a cancellation or extinguishment of debt where debt unenforceable pursuant to probate or similar proceeding; (6) a discharge of indebtedness pursuant to agreement between the creditor and debtor for less than full consideration; (7) a discharge of indebtedness pursuant to a decision by the creditor to discontinue collection activity and  (8) the expiration of the nonpayment testing period.

So what does this mean?  This means that unless you have received something from the creditor stating that the debt is forgiven in addition to the 1099-C, they still have a right to collect on it unless one of the above exceptions applies.  Collection on debt where a 1099-C has been issued is happening to many people in California who have junior deeds of trusts against their homes.  They received a 1099-C from the lender and then years later someone who bought the debt starts foreclosing on the property.

So what should you do?  If you have received a 1099-C from a lender, especially a lender with a lien against your home, you should call the lender and see if they have actually “forgiven” the debt.  If they have, you need something in writing that says exactly that i.e. the creditor is not going to pursue any further collection on the debt.  In addition, if the lien is against your home, the lender must reconvey the deed of trust.  If the lender will not issue you a letter saying that the debt has been forgiven, you need to seek legal counsel immediately.  A 1099-C without further evidence stating the debt was forgiven is a ticking time bomb. 

1099-C issues are complicated and generally misunderstood.  If you have questions, seek counsel.  I see people for a FREE 30 minute consultation in my offices located in Walnut Creek and Brentwood. 

WE ARE A DEBT RELIEF AGENCY. WE HELP PEOPLE FILE BANKRUPTCY RELIEF UNDER THE BANKRUPTCY CODE. THIS INFORMATION IS NOT PROVIDED AS LEGAL ADVICE AND SHOULD NOT BE RELIED UPON IN MAKING A DECISION REGARDING A VOLUNTARY DEFAULT, SHORT SALE, FORECLOSURE OR BANKRUPTCY.  THIS INFORMATION IS NOT A SUBSTITUTE FOR OBTAINING TAX & LEGAL ADVICE REGARDING AN INDIVIDUAL SITUATION.   © 2015

New Law on Short Sale - What you Should Know to Protect Yourself

Effective July 15, 2011, California Code of Civil Procedure (“CCP”) 580(e) was amended to prohibit a deficiency judgment on any loan secured solely by a deed of trust on a 1-4 unit dwelling sold in a short sale.  Enough legal jargon…what exactly does this mean and how does apply to you?

First, it means that if your lenders agree to a short sale, it will release you from your personal liability on loans secured solely by a deed of trust against a dwelling of 1- 4 units.  If the lenders want the short sale to go through, they will have to be satisfied with the proceeds from the sale.  The banks can no longer demand that borrowers sign promissory notes… AND no more tricking borrowers into believing that releasing of the lien was in fact releasing their personal liability.  The lenders do not have to agree to the short sale, but if they agree, they cannot come after you once the short sale is completed.  However, if you think this is too good to be true…you’re right. Keep reading!

Second, there is no requirement for a release of personal liability on anything other than a consensual lien i.e. no requirement to release judgment lien or liens placed on the property such as by a homeowners association or taxing authority.  These parties do not have to agree to accept the proceeds from the sale as payment in full. The forgiveness of personal liability also does not apply to borrowers who are corporations, limited liability companies, limited partnership or political subdivision of the state.  In addition, it also does not prohibit the lender from obtaining a judgment for fraud with respect to the short sale or waste committed to the property.

Third, CCP 580(e) does not release you from any tax liability.  Remember, every short sale has tax implications. The IRS/State Franchise Tax Board wants to know two things: 1) Did you make any money on the deal and 2) Did you borrow any money which was not repaid?  If you made money on the deal, including taking out cash to buy another house, car, pay off credit card, you may have a gain. If you borrowed money which was not repaid, you will have Cancellation of Debt Income (“CODI”).  CODI will be taxable to you at your current tax rate unless an exception applies. Make sure you know all the tax implications before the short sale is completed.  If there is CODI, it can be discharged in bankruptcy, but only if the bankruptcy is filed prior to the short sale being completed.

In conclusion, CCP 580(e) is a mixed bag for consumers.  It may help reduce personal liability while increasing tax liability.  There is no question that this new law is going to hurt the lenders and help the IRS and State Franchise Tax Board.  This will be found money for the tax man.  Borrowers will see the forgiveness of personal liability and completely disregard the tax consequences.   Don’t be one of those people!  If you are considering a short sale, seek legal advice prior to starting the short sale process.  This is a complicated area of the law, but a bankruptcy or real estate attorney should be able to make to an analysis of your particular situation fairly quickly.   I see people for a FREE 30 minute consultations at my offices located in Walnut Creek, Antioch and Brentwood.

THIS INFORMATION IS NOT PROVIDED AS LEGAL ADVICE AND SHOULD NOT BE RELIED UPON IN MAKING ANY DECISION REGARDING A VOLUNTARY DEFAULT, SHORT SALE, FORECLOSURE OR BANKRUPTCY.  THIS INFORMATION IS NOT A SUBSTITUTE FOR OBTAINING TAX & LEGAL ADVICE REGARDING AN INDIVIDUAL SITUATION.         GRIMESBKLAW.COM  (925) 323-7772     

© 2011 Joan Grimes